Scott Schoeneweis…crusher of hopes, destroyer of dreams, losing pitcher of last night’s Mets game – a debacle I was on hand to see.
Now, before I begin my dissection of the disaster that has been the Scott Schoeneweis Era, let me preface what I’m going to write by saying that he is certainly not the sole reason the Mets lost Tuesday night’s game against the Cardinals 5-3 in 11 innings. In fact, the game probably never should have been in his hands in the 11th inning. The Mets offense, once again, was missing in action against an inferior starting pitcher. The usually steady Jose Valentin made two critical errors leading to two runs. And finally, Willie Randolph managed his bullpen poorly, leaving Aaron Heilman in the game to begin the 7th despite this being his 4th appearance in 5 days, and choosing to use Schoeneweis when he did in the 11th. It’s with that last point in mind that I’m going to pick up my analysis of Schoeneweis, the most hated man in Flushing – the way in which decisions by others have affected his performance and the perception of him most fans have. Is it all really his fault?
Scott Schoeneweis was signed to a 3-year, 10.5 million dollar contract in the offseason. He has put up a sub-4 ERA in only two seasons since his debut in 1999, and posted an unspectacular 4.88 last season with the Blue Jays and Reds. It’s apparent the first mistake was Omar Minaya’s for overpaying and overextending to give what on the surface is a mediocre relief pitcher a ridiculous amount of money for a ridiculous length of time.
Despite his mediocre overall numbers, Schoeneweis does have a track record of having some redeeming qualities as a major league pitcher – namely, his ability to get left-handed hitters out. From 2004 to 2006, lefties hit only .220 against Scott with a .563 OPS, while righties tore him apart to a .295/.846 tune. Clearly, if he’s to be effective, it’s to be as a left-handed specialist. Let’s look at his splits this season:
vs. LHB: 44 AB, 10 H, 0 HR, .222 AVG, .616 OPS
vs. RHB: 54 AB, 18 H, 4 HR, .333 AVG, 1.128 OPS
Note, first off, the staggering difference, which is in line with his career norms. However, also note that he’s faced more right-handed batters than left-handed batters this season, despite having a track record of being an effective pitcher only against left-handed hitters. This is a failure in managing, and this falls strictly on Willie Randolph. Ignoring his career trends, he has used him all year in situations where he historically has not succeeded, his latest appearance being no different. The first batter he faced tonight, Brendan Ryan, is a right handed batter and hit the tie-breaking home run (the first of his career) in the 11th inning. There’s no denying Scott Schoeneweis has been especially terrible this season against righties and has cost the Mets a number of games. However, there’s also no denying that he was overpaid to begin with and continues to be misused by Willie Randolph. Unfortunately, it was reached a point where he may not be redeemable in the eyes of Mets fans, but remember – Scott Schoeneweis didn’t give himself millions of dollars to sign here, and he’s not the one putting himself into games in situations where he is likely to fail.
One more interesting tidbit: Schoeneweis now has a 9.53 ERA at Shea and a 0.00 ERA on the road. Last night’s game was probably the first time I have ever been in Shea when everyone in the stadium (outside of Willie Randolph) knew the Mets were going to lose when a pitcher entered the game. I can only describe the feeling in the park as a bizarre, frightened silence. He’s probably reached a point of no return as far as pitching at Shea is concerned and he’s signed for two and a half more years, making his trade value negligible at this point. The only thing that is certain is that as long as he continues to be misused, things can’t possibly get any better, and Scott Schoeneweis will continue to be the most hated relief pitcher in Flushing since Mel Rojas toed the rubber almost a decade ago.
Thanks to the crew at Mets Rant for inspiring me to write this evaluation of Metsdom’s least-favorite lefty for everyone out there.
Other observations from Tuesday night:
- I was happy David Wright was hitting fourth. Carlos Delgado continues to follow in the footsteps of Robbie Alomar as a Met, looking unbelievably lost.
- The Yankee Stadium-style chanting of player’s names needs to stop…as of two years ago.
- We got a laugh on the way out of the parking lot when we spotted a coach bus run by “Kum Gang Tours Inc”. Kum Gang Tours! There isn’t even a joke needed. This pretty much made my night, outside of the Mets’ failure.
It was only the third game I’ve been to all year, after going to 16 in 2005 and 11 last year. Spending a night at Shea is pretty much one of my favorite things to do, so hopefully I can get out there more often as the summer goes on. There are other factors making that difficult, though, like the whole not-really-having-a-job thing. I’m going to work on that…
I also promise this isn’t going to turn into a baseball-only blog. I just couldn’t resist the last couple of nights.